MSNBC makes a joke of domestic violence in an incident where a Florida woman was hit in the face and nearly killed by her boyfriend.
I saw the article (reported on 11/18/2008) reported on MSNBC.com titled “Cops: Man uses sandwich to assault girlfriend
Authorities aren’t saying if the weapon he wielded was a club sandwich” . The article was listed on the front page of MSNBC under “Weird News”. Other news sources have reported the incident, noting the strangeness of the assault but not going to the extent MSNBC has by mocking the attack, and its severity.
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/27793459/from/ET/
The article details an incident where a 19 year old woman, Brittany Gonzales, from Port St. Lucie, Florida
was driving on Interstate 95 when an arguement erupted with her boyfriend, Emmanuelle Rodriguez, 19. Also in the car was their baby son, seven months old. The boyfriend became angry then allegedly hit Brittany in the arm and the face with a sandwich. Apparently the incident is funny, as MSNBC reports: “Police haven’t said what type of sandwich was involved.” Brittany’s glasses were knocked off due to the force of the blows. Keep in mind that Emmanuelle was sitting in the seat next to Brittany, so to hit her to the extent that her glasses were knocked off meant that he struck hard. I’m only speculating but it’s possible the sandwich absorbed some of the force. Had Emmanuele hit Brittany in the head with an open hand or closed fist, he could have knocked her unconscious, caused contusions or broken bones.
Brittany who was driving anywhere from 60-70 mph on the Interstate, nearly lost control of the car because she could not see after her glasses were knocked off. It is also reported, “…the man then allegedly ripped off the rear-view mirror and used it to shatter the windshield.” The baby in the back seat was reported to be sleeping and was not hurt. Brittany exited the freeway and then asked Emmanuelle to get out of the car, which he did. He was later arrested.
MSNBC concludes the article by making jokes about the sandwich, referring to it as a “club sandwich”. The reporting of the incident by MSNBC is not only insensitive but deplorable. Making jokes about abuse–and minimizing the seriousness of the assault is not funny. This kind of attitude that implies “it’s not that bad” and suggests you can merely shrug off the incident is exactly what prevents battered women from coming forward and getting help.
Emmanuelle Rodriguez was charged and freed on $7500 bail. The most dangerous time for battered women is when they leave or attempt to leave the abuser; violence often escalates during this time. Women who do not get help or support may return to the abuse, or be killed. Now that Mr. Rodrigues on bail, he is roaming the streets and poses a very real danger to Brittany and her son–and anyone who may be trying to help them. I hope Brittany gets help from the police and a battered women’s shelter. It is imperitive that she set up a safety plan.
I want Brittany to know that she deserves to be treated with love and respect. It is not okay for anyone to hurt her–or laugh at her struggles. I am very sorry that people think its funny that Brittany was assaulted, I cannot magine how terrified she must have felt. Brittany, you are very brave to go to the police. I know it’s very hard to talk about painful things, especially when someone you love is hurting you. I know it’s not easy to leave the situation–your whole life will change, and you will need to make alot of sacrifices. But it’s worth it. You will be safe, you will heal and most of all you are giving your son a better life. There are people who care, and who want to help. Don’t be afraid to ask. There are women who have survived abuse and will understand, you are not alone. Have hope, things will get better. I will keep you in my prayers, and wish the best for you and your son.
Let’s think about this for a moment…
5.3 million women are abused each year, 1,232 women killed from abuse. We know the names of some of these women: Laci and Connor Peterson, Nicole Brown Simpson, Loretta Lynn, and Robin Givens.
In 2001, more than half a million American women were victims of violent acts committed by their partners–men they were in relationships with.
In the United States alone, 324,000 pregnant women are abused by their partners. Homicide is the leading cause of death for pregnant women.
Children, like the seven month old child mentioned above, exposed to domestic violence typically fall into three categories (and/or a combination of all three):
* Witnessing a violent event
* Being a victim of a violent event
* Experiencing the aftermath of violence
Domestic violence is extremely traumatic for children. Children may used as a tool for the perpetrator to abuse or exact revenge on the victim (their mother). Children may be hurt when caught between fighting parents. A child may be hurt trying to protect the mother. And often, these children are at a higher risk of becoming a victim of child abuse or neglect. These children may suffer psychological or physical harm from being exposed to violence–often the scars are lifelong.
Abusers are often repeat offenders–they will abuse and terrorize their families time and time again.
Victims of abuse often do not come forward because they fear retaliation from perpetrators–or they will not be believed. Some fear they will be mocked, as MSNBC has done.
I don’t think this is funny. MSNBC should apologize for their insensitive, deplorable reporting of this story.
Quotes:
“Children who are exposed to domestic violence are more likely to exhibit behavioral and physical health problems including depression, anxiety, and violence towards peers. They are also more likely to attempt suicide, abuse drugs and alcohol, run away from home, engage in teenage prostitution, and commit sexual assault crimes.” — Family Violence Prevention Fund
Child Welfare Information Gateway, “Possible Symptoms in Children Exposed to Domestic Violence “
Sleeplessness, fears of going to sleep, nightmares, dreams of danger;
Physical symptoms such as headaches or stomachaches;
Hypervigilance to danger or being hurt;
Fighting with others, hurting other children or animals;
Temper tantrums or defiant behavior;
Withdrawal from people or typical activities;
Listlessness, depression, low energy;
Feelings of loneliness and isolation;
Current or subsequent substance abuse;
Suicide attempts or engaging in dangerous behavior;
Poor school performance;
Difficulties concentrating and paying attention;
Fears of being separated from the nonabusing parent;
Feeling that his or her best is not good enough;
Taking on adult or parental responsibilities;
Excessive worrying;
Bed-wetting or regression to earlier developmental stages;
Dissociation;
Identifying with or mirroring behaviors of the abuser.
Additional Information:
WFTV.com “Fla. Man Accused Of Sandwich Assault
Police: 19-Year-Old Woman Struck In Face While Driving”
http://www.wftv.com/nationalnews/18017024/detail.html
National Domestic Violence Hotline: “Help is available to callers 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. Hotline advocates are available for victims and anyone calling on their behalf to provide crisis intervention, safety planning, information and referrals to agencies in all 50 states.”
1-800-799-SAFE (7233) or TTY 1-800-787-3224
http://www.ndvh.org/
Child Welfare Information Gateway, “Children’s Exposure to Domestic Violence”:
http://www.enotalone.com/article/9996.html
End Abuse, “Domestic Violence is a Serious, Widespread Social Problem in America: The Facts”:
http://endabuse.org/resources/facts/
Family Violence Prevention Fund, “The Facts on Children and Domestic Violence”:
http://endabuse.org/resources/facts/Children.pdf
Minnesota Center Against Violence and Abuse: Barbara J. Hart’s Collected Writings (When Batterers Kill, Children and Domestic Violence, Intervention, Legacy Advocacy and More)
http://www.mincava.umn.edu/documents/hart/hart.html
Resistance, Reluctance, and Readiness in Perpetrators of Abuse Against Women and Children by Katreena L. Scott and Colin L King
http://tva.sagepub.com/cgi/content/refs/8/4/401